People & HR

What Makes Someone a Good Hire for a Growing Business?

What makes someone a good hire for a growing business? Learn how to evaluate candidates beyond resumes, assess transferable skills and learning ability, and make better hiring decisions.

What makes someone a good hire for a growing business? Learn how to evaluate candidates beyond resumes, assess transferable skills and learning ability, and make better hiring decisions.

PUBLISHED

READING TIME

15 min read

Candidates waiting for interviews

People & HR

15 min read

Hiring Is About More Than Filling a Position

Hiring for a growing business presents a particular challenge. The responsibilities that exist today may look considerably different a year from now. Teams are small, roles overlap, processes are still being established, and employees often find themselves taking on responsibilities beyond their original remit.

In such an environment, finding someone who can perform the responsibilities listed in a job description is only part of the consideration. Equally important is whether they can navigate unfamiliar situations, acquire new skills and remain effective as the organisation changes.

But what actually makes someone a good hire?

Experience, qualifications and technical competence matter. So do judgement, motivation, the ability to work with others and an individual's willingness to learn. The challenge is understanding how these qualities come together in a particular person, and whether they are relevant to the business and the role being filled.

A good hiring decision, therefore, requires more than identifying the most impressive resume or conducting a successful interview. It requires understanding both the work that needs to be done and the person who might be doing it.

Start by Understanding What the Business Actually Needs

Before evaluating candidates, it is worth examining the position itself.

Growing businesses frequently hire in response to immediate requirements. Someone is overwhelmed with work, a new client has come on board, or a particular function needs to be established. Recruitment begins with a designation and a list of responsibilities, often without much consideration of how the role might evolve.

This can lead to hiring someone whose experience matches the job description but whose capabilities are poorly aligned with the actual requirements of the business.

A more useful starting point is to identify the outcomes expected from the role.

What should this person be able to accomplish independently? Which responsibilities require prior expertise? Where will they need guidance or training? What problems are they expected to solve? How might the role change as the business grows?

For example, a small business hiring its first operations manager may need someone who can establish processes, coordinate people, identify inefficiencies and make decisions with limited supervision. Experience managing an established operational system may be relevant, but it is not necessarily equivalent to the ability to build one.

This distinction should inform both the job description and the evaluation criteria.

It also helps separate essential requirements from preferences. A qualification, a particular designation or experience in a specific industry may be genuinely necessary for some positions. In others, these requirements may simply reflect how similar roles have traditionally been filled.

The more clearly a business understands what it needs, the easier it becomes to recognise candidates who may be suitable through different professional paths.

A Good Candidate Does Not Always Have the Most Conventional Resume

Resumes remain an important part of recruitment, but they are best understood as a starting point rather than a definitive assessment of capability.

A candidate's professional history provides context. It tells you something about the environments they have worked in, the responsibilities they have encountered and the opportunities they may have had to develop particular skills.

What it does not necessarily tell you is how well they performed, how much they learned or whether their experience translates to your organisation.

Two candidates with similar designations and years of experience may have developed very different capabilities. Someone who has worked in a smaller organisation may have handled a broader range of responsibilities. Someone from a larger organisation may bring considerable depth in a particular function, along with experience working within established processes.

Neither background is inherently better. Their relevance depends on what the business needs.

This is where skills-based hiring becomes useful. Rather than screening candidates exclusively on qualifications, previous employers or years of experience, employers also consider demonstrated capabilities and transferable skills.

Indian hiring research has reflected this shift. Mercer | Mettl's India Graduate Skill Index 2025 identifies learning agility, critical thinking and communication among the competencies employers increasingly value. Indeed India's 2025 research on hiring quality also highlights willingness to learn and soft skills as important considerations.

These findings, particularly those drawn from graduate and campus hiring, should not be interpreted as a universal description of every recruitment process. They nevertheless reinforce an important point: professional experience and the ability to apply, extend and develop that experience are related, but not interchangeable.

What can employers do differently?

When screening resumes, consider the following:

  • Look for responsibilities and outcomes, not just designations.

  • Identify experiences that demonstrate relevant capabilities, even if they come from another industry or role.

  • Examine the progression of responsibilities rather than relying exclusively on years of employment.

  • Consider whether a candidate has worked in environments that resemble the conditions of your business.

  • Distinguish between skills that are essential upon joining and those that can be developed subsequently.

This does not mean disregarding experience or lowering requirements. It means being deliberate about which requirements actually matter.

Look for Evidence of Learning and Adaptability

One of the advantages of hiring for a growing business is that the role may offer opportunities to develop beyond its initial responsibilities. The corresponding challenge is finding people who can navigate that development.

Learning ability and adaptability are frequently mentioned in discussions about hiring, but they can be difficult to assess. Candidates may describe themselves as quick learners, comfortable with change or capable of taking initiative. These descriptions are useful only when supported by actual experiences.

A more informative approach is to examine how someone has responded when they had to learn something unfamiliar, take on a new responsibility or work through a problem without a clear solution.

Consider asking candidates:

  • What is something you had to learn recently to perform your work better?

  • Tell me about a responsibility you took on that was unfamiliar to you.

  • Describe a situation where you had to work with incomplete information.

  • What is something you initially struggled with but eventually became good at?

  • Tell me about a time you received feedback that changed your approach.

The value of these questions lies in the conversation that follows.

What prompted the situation? How did the candidate approach it? What did they find difficult? How did they learn? What would they do differently now?

The answers can provide insight into whether someone approaches unfamiliar situations with curiosity and initiative, whether they recognise their own limitations and whether they can reflect on their experiences.

Learning ability is particularly relevant when hiring for positions where the business expects responsibilities to evolve. It should not, however, become a substitute for essential technical knowledge or the capabilities required to perform the job from day one.

A Candidate's Approach to Problems Can Tell You a Great Deal

Growing businesses often encounter problems that have not been fully anticipated or documented. Employees may need to make decisions, coordinate with others and find practical solutions without relying on established procedures for every situation.

This makes problem-solving and judgement particularly valuable.

But problem-solving should not be confused with having an answer to everything. A good candidate may recognise that they lack information, identify what needs to be understood and determine when to seek help.

In many situations, the quality of their reasoning is more informative than whether they arrive at an immediately correct answer.

A practical way to evaluate this is to introduce a situation relevant to the role and ask the candidate how they would approach it.

For instance, an operations candidate could be asked how they would handle a recurring delay involving multiple teams. A research candidate might be given conflicting information and asked how they would establish what is reliable. Someone being hired for a generalist position could be presented with competing priorities and asked how they would decide what to address first.

The purpose is not to test whether candidates can guess what the interviewer wants to hear. It is to understand how they break down a problem, what information they consider important, what assumptions they make and how they arrive at a decision.

A short, relevant exercise can often provide more useful evidence than a hypothetical question alone.

The Interview Should Help You Understand the Person

Structured interviews have an important place in recruitment. Establishing evaluation criteria beforehand, asking comparable questions and recording relevant observations helps employers make more consistent decisions.

But particularly in smaller businesses, an interview serves another purpose.

The founder or business leader hiring someone is also trying to understand what it might be like to work with that person. How do they approach responsibility? What do they value in a workplace? How do they think about collaboration, independence and professional growth? What kind of environment allows them to perform at their best?

These are not always questions that can be answered through a prescribed set of competencies.

An open-ended conversation can be particularly revealing. Discussing a candidate's professional experiences, aspirations, expectations and working preferences often provides a more complete understanding of the person than a succession of formal questions.

The founder's involvement is valuable here. In a small organisation, a new employee can have a considerable influence on the team and its working environment. The founder is often best positioned to explain the organisation's expectations, understand the candidate's motivations and assess whether the relationship is likely to work in practice.

This does not mean hiring people simply because they share the founder's personality, background or preferences. Culture fit is better understood as compatibility with the organisation's working values, expectations and ways of collaborating.

It is also worth paying attention to what candidates ask.

An interview is a two-way conversation, and the questions a candidate raises can be revealing in their own right. Questions about responsibilities, decision-making, team dynamics, expectations, opportunities to learn or how success is evaluated can offer insight into what matters to them and how they think about the role.

The absence of a particular question, however, should not automatically be interpreted negatively. Candidates differ in confidence, experience and their ability to articulate what they want to know, and some may simply need more information or a more comfortable setting to ask.

The point is to understand the conversation in its entirety rather than evaluating candidates exclusively on the quality of their answers.

Ultimately, the interview should help both sides determine whether the opportunity and the person are a good match. A candidate may possess the required capabilities and still find that the role, expectations or working environment are unsuitable for them. Recognising that early is just as valuable as identifying a strong hire.

What a Candidate Can Demonstrate Is Often More Useful Than What They Can Describe

There is a limit to what interviews can establish.

A candidate may explain how they would approach a problem convincingly without necessarily being able to execute that approach. Conversely, someone who communicates less confidently in an interview may demonstrate considerable competence when given a practical task.

This is where work samples and role-relevant assessments become useful.

A work sample allows an employer to observe a candidate performing an activity related to the actual responsibilities of the position. The exercise might involve analysing information, responding to a simulated situation, developing a solution or completing a small assignment.

The assessment should reflect the level of work expected from the candidate. It should also be proportionate in scope and duration, with clear instructions and reasonable conditions.

For capabilities that are expected to be developed after joining, a different approach can be more informative. A candidate can be introduced to an unfamiliar tool or concept, given sufficient guidance to understand it and asked to apply what they have learned.

The assessment then becomes less about prior familiarity and more about how they engage with new information.

Do they understand the instructions? Can they identify what is relevant? Do they ask appropriate questions? Can they apply the information to the task? What happens when they encounter difficulty?

These observations provide a more grounded understanding of how someone might approach learning on the job.

The exercise should not be treated as a definitive measure of potential. Familiarity, confidence, time constraints and the quality of instructions can all influence performance. But when used alongside interviews and other evidence, practical assessments can reveal aspects of a candidate that conventional screening might miss.

Culture Fit Is Not About Hiring People Who Are Similar to You

Culture fit is one of the more frequently discussed considerations in hiring, particularly in smaller organisations where teams work closely together.

It is also one of the easiest concepts to misunderstand.

A candidate who shares the founder's interests, communicates in a similar manner or comes from a familiar professional background may feel like an obvious fit. That familiarity, however, does not necessarily translate into effective collaboration or strong performance.

A more useful way to evaluate culture fit is to consider how a candidate's working preferences and behaviours align with the organisation's actual environment.

Does the role require considerable independence, or will the employee work closely with others? How are decisions made? Is the organisation comfortable with experimentation, or does the work require considerable adherence to established processes? What expectations exist around communication, accountability and responsibility?

These are meaningful considerations because they affect how people work together.

They also make it possible to recognise candidates who may bring different perspectives or working styles while still being compatible with the organisation.

For founders, this is particularly important. Building a team should not mean surrounding yourself with people who think exactly as you do. It should mean bringing together people who can work effectively towards shared objectives, understand their responsibilities and contribute to the organisation's development.

The Best Candidate Is Not Always the One Who Needs the Least Training

A common consideration in hiring is how quickly someone can become productive.

This is understandable. Small businesses have limited resources, and a new employee who requires substantial support can place additional demands on an already stretched team.

But immediate productivity is only one consideration.

A candidate who has performed the same responsibilities for several years may require relatively little training. Another candidate may need some initial support but possess capabilities that become increasingly valuable as the role develops.

The decision depends on what the business needs and what it can reasonably support.

For a position involving critical technical responsibilities, prior competence may be indispensable. For a role with a broader remit or substantial opportunities for development, transferable skills and learning ability may deserve greater consideration.

The important thing is to make this distinction before recruitment begins.

Employers should be clear about what they expect someone to know upon joining, what they are willing to teach and how much support they can realistically provide.

Hiring for potential is meaningful only when the organisation is prepared to create the conditions in which that potential can develop.

Making a Hiring Decision With Greater Confidence

Ultimately, no single interview, resume or assessment can establish whether someone will be a successful hire.

A more considered decision brings together several kinds of evidence.

A candidate's professional history provides context. Their demonstrated skills establish what they can do. Their approach to unfamiliar situations offers insight into how they might learn and adapt. The interview helps both sides understand expectations, motivations and working compatibility. Practical assessments provide an opportunity to observe relevant capabilities directly.

These considerations should be evaluated against the requirements of the role, rather than a generic list of desirable employee qualities.

One simple practice that can help is to document the reasons for a hiring decision.

Before making an offer, ask:

  • What evidence establishes that this candidate can perform the essential responsibilities?

  • What relevant capabilities or experiences distinguish them?

  • Which skills or responsibilities will require further development?

  • What did we learn about their working preferences and motivations?

  • Are their expectations compatible with the role and the organisation?

  • Can we realistically provide the support they will need?

These questions help distinguish a decision grounded in evidence from one based primarily on an impression.

They also make it easier to communicate expectations after the candidate joins and evaluate whether the hiring decision was successful.

A Good Hire Is a Good Match for the Business and the Person

Hiring for a growing business is ultimately an exercise in judgement.

The objective is not to find someone who possesses every desirable quality, has followed the perfect career path or can perform every responsibility without assistance.

It is to identify someone whose capabilities, experience, motivations and working preferences are well suited to the position, while recognising what they may be able to contribute as the organisation develops.

That requires employers to look beyond conventional indicators of suitability, but also to remain realistic about the responsibilities they need to fill.

A good hire brings the right combination of competence, judgement and willingness to develop. They understand what is expected of them, have the foundation to perform their responsibilities and can contribute constructively to the environment in which they work.

Just as importantly, the organisation understands what it is asking of them and is prepared to support their contribution.

For a growing business, that is what makes hiring more than filling a vacancy. It is an opportunity to build a team that can grow alongside the organisation.

Building a Hiring Process for Your Business?

As businesses grow, recruitment becomes easier to manage when roles, responsibilities and expectations are defined clearly.

De Facto provides practical HR services for growing businesses, including recruitment support, hiring systems, HR policies and people operations.

Explore our People & HR services to understand how we can support your business as your team grows.

Explore People & HR Services

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.